Hyderabad

Hyderabad consumer forum slams Manipal Cigna for unjustified health insurance claim rejection, orders to pay ₹3.5 lakh | Hyderabad News

Hyderabad consumer forum slams Manipal Cigna for unjustified health insurance claim rejection, orders to pay ₹3.5 lakh

Hyderabad: A district consumer forum in Hyderabad has directed Manipal Cigna Health Insurance Company to reimburse Rs 3.5 lakh in medical expenses and pay Rs 50,000 as compensation to a 43-year-old man, holding that the insurer unjustifiably repudiated his claim on grounds of alleged misrepresentation and non-disclosure of material facts.The complainant, P Venkanna, stated that he had obtained a group health insurance policy from Manipal Cigna Health Insurance Company by paying an annual premium of Rs 17,964. The policy, valid from Nov 17, 2022, to Nov 16, 2023, carried a sum insured of Rs 15 lakh. He also issued an ECS mandate to renew the policy for the subsequent year.On Sept 29, 2023, Venkanna was admitted to a private hospital in Kothapet with complaints of breathlessness and swelling in his feet. He underwent treatment until Oct 13, incurring medical and hospitalisation expenses of about Rs 8 lakh.On Dec 12, 2023, he submitted a reimbursement claim to the insurer. However, the company repudiated the claim and terminated the policy, alleging misrepresentation and non-disclosure of material facts.Aggrieved by the decision, Venkanna approached the consumer forum, alleging that the repudiation was arbitrary, baseless and amounted to deficiency in service.In its written submission, the insurance company denied the allegations and maintained that the claim had been rejected on grounds of fraud after several discrepancies were allegedly noticed in the claim documents. It claimed that Venkanna had a history of urethral stricture dating back about 10 years and consumed four pegs of alcohol daily. The insurer also alleged that he had raised a false claim, stating that he had paid only Rs 3.5 lakh against the total hospital bill of Rs 8.69 lakh, with the remaining amount having been waived as a discount.After examining the submissions, the bench observed that the insurer had made only general allegations regarding discrepancies in the hospital records but had failed to produce supporting documents or cogent evidence to substantiate the alleged discrepancies or fraudulent disclosures.The forum further noted that there was no evidence to establish that Venkanna or his treating doctor had concealed or denied his past medical history. It observed that even if he had suffered from urethral stricture 10 years earlier, the condition could not be treated as a pre-existing disease under the policy. Similarly, the alleged daily consumption of alcohol could not, by itself, constitute a valid ground for repudiating the claim.Holding that the insurer had failed to establish any element of fraud, the bench concluded that the repudiation of the claim was arbitrary and unjustified.With regard to the reimbursement amount, the forum noted that neither party had produced the medical bills to establish the exact amount paid by the complainant. However, as the insurer itself had admitted that Venkanna had paid Rs 3.5 lakh, the bench directed it to reimburse the amount.Accordingly, the consumer forum directed the insurance company to pay Rs 3.5 lakh towards medical expenses, Rs 50,000 as compensation for the mental agony and hardship suffered by the complainant, and an additional Rs 10,000 towards litigation expenses.


Source link

Related Articles

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Back to top button
×
newsnation.aanest.com
Logo
Date of Publish : 20 November 2026, 1:57 am Digital Edition : News nation
Hyderabad consumer forum slams Manipal Cigna for unjustified health insurance claim rejection, orders to pay ₹3.5 lakh | Hyderabad News

Hyderabad: A district consumer forum in Hyderabad has directed Manipal Cigna Health Insurance Company to reimburse Rs 3.5 lakh in medical expenses and pay Rs 50,000 as compensation to a 43-year-old man, holding that the insurer unjustifiably repudiated his claim on grounds of alleged misrepresentation and non-disclosure of material facts.The complainant, P Venkanna, stated that he had obtained a group health insurance policy from Manipal Cigna Health Insurance Company by paying an annual premium of Rs 17,964. The policy, valid from Nov 17, 2022, to Nov 16, 2023, carried a sum insured of Rs 15 lakh. He also issued an ECS mandate to renew the policy for the subsequent year.On Sept 29, 2023, Venkanna was admitted to a private hospital in Kothapet with complaints of breathlessness and swelling in his feet. He underwent treatment until Oct 13, incurring medical and hospitalisation expenses of about Rs 8 lakh.On Dec 12, 2023, he submitted a reimbursement claim to the insurer. However, the company repudiated the claim and terminated the policy, alleging misrepresentation and non-disclosure of material facts.Aggrieved by the decision, Venkanna approached the consumer forum, alleging that the repudiation was arbitrary, baseless and amounted to deficiency in service.In its written submission, the insurance company denied the allegations and maintained that the claim had been rejected on grounds of fraud after several discrepancies were allegedly noticed in the claim documents. It claimed that Venkanna had a history of urethral stricture dating back about 10 years and consumed four pegs of alcohol daily. The insurer also alleged that he had raised a false claim, stating that he had paid only Rs 3.5 lakh against the total hospital bill of Rs 8.69 lakh, with the remaining amount having been waived as a discount.After examining the submissions, the bench observed that the insurer had made only general allegations regarding discrepancies in the hospital records but had failed to produce supporting documents or cogent evidence to substantiate the alleged discrepancies or fraudulent disclosures.The forum further noted that there was no evidence to establish that Venkanna or his treating doctor had concealed or denied his past medical history. It observed that even if he had suffered from urethral stricture 10 years earlier, the condition could not be treated as a pre-existing disease under the policy. Similarly, the alleged daily consumption of alcohol could not, by itself, constitute a valid ground for repudiating the claim.Holding that the insurer had failed to establish any element of fraud, the bench concluded that the repudiation of the claim was arbitrary and unjustified.With regard to the reimbursement amount, the forum noted that neither party had produced the medical bills to establish the exact amount paid by the complainant. However, as the insurer itself had admitted that Venkanna had paid Rs 3.5 lakh, the bench directed it to reimburse the amount.Accordingly, the consumer forum directed the insurance company to pay Rs 3.5 lakh towards medical expenses, Rs 50,000 as compensation for the mental agony and hardship suffered by the complainant, and an additional Rs 10,000 towards litigation expenses.

Source link