World

A Philadelphia teacher was fired after refusing weekly Covid tests, but not one elected school board member attended his termination hearing; five years later, Pennsylvania’s top court upheld a ruling in his favour

A Philadelphia teacher was fired after refusing weekly Covid tests, but not one elected school board member attended his termination hearing; five years later, Pennsylvania's top court upheld a ruling in his favour
AI representation/ChatGPT

A Philadelphia teacher who lost his job after refusing to undergo weekly Covid-19 tests has won a legal battle that began during the pandemic. The Pennsylvania Supreme Court has ruled in his favour, finding that the school district violated state law by holding his termination hearing without a single elected school board member present.The ruling, delivered on November 17, concerns Neal Follman, a teacher in the School District of Philadelphia. The court upheld an earlier decision ordering the district to reinstate him with back pay unless it properly terminates his employment in accordance with the law.The case turned on a question of procedure: can a school board delegate a tenured teacher’s dismissal hearing entirely to an appointed hearing officer, then decide the teacher’s fate by reviewing the record afterwards? The state’s highest court said no.

Why the teacher refused Covid testing

According to the Pennsylvania Department of Education’s official record, Follman was employed by the Philadelphia School District from January 2010 and worked at Constitution High School during the 2020-21 school year.On February 22, 2021, the district’s then superintendent, William Hite, informed staff that employees returning to schools for in-person learning would have to undergo weekly Covid-19 testing. The testing was to be carried out by medical providers at school premises during working hours. Employees could seek an exemption on medical grounds.Follman submitted a refusal and exemption request on May 7, 2021. He listed concerns including the test’s emergency-use authorisation, its accuracy, the handling of testing materials and the company administering the tests. However, he did not complete the section of the form asking him to provide a justification for a medical exemption.The district told him that his reasons were insufficient and warned that disciplinary action would follow if he continued to refuse testing. Follman maintained his refusal. His school principal, Brianna Dunn-Robb, recommended his termination. A district hearing officer also recommended that he be dismissed and suspended without pay while the decision was pending.The school board initially adopted a resolution supporting the termination recommendation in August 2021. Follman was then issued a statement of charges and given the opportunity to challenge the proposed dismissal.

The termination hearing that no elected board member attended

Photo: Canva

Photo: Canva

Follman chose to contest the proposed termination through a hearing under Pennsylvania’s Local Agency Law. The hearing was initially scheduled for September 13, 2021, but was postponed. The district later decided to hold it virtually, despite objections from Follman and his lawyer, who had sought an in-person hearing.The hearing eventually took place by videoconference in February 2022. No elected member of the Philadelphia Board of Education attended. Instead, the board appointed a hearing officer, Rudolph Garcia, to preside over the proceedings. Follman challenged the arrangement, arguing that Pennsylvania’s Public School Code required him to be heard before the elected school board directors themselves.On August 18, 2022, the board voted 9-0 to dismiss him. It adopted the hearing officer’s findings and conclusions. The Pennsylvania Department of Education’s Secretary of Education initially upheld the dismissal. The secretary reasoned that the board could appoint a hearing officer as long as its members reviewed the findings and made an independent decision based on the record. Follman appealed.

What the courts said

In July 2024, the Commonwealth Court of Pennsylvania reversed the secretary’s decision. It held that the school board had not complied with the statutory procedure for dismissing a tenured teacher. The court ordered Follman’s reinstatement with back pay unless the district properly terminated his employment.The Philadelphia School District challenged that decision before the Pennsylvania Supreme Court. It argued that the Public School Code allowed school boards to delegate the task of conducting termination hearings to appointed hearing officers. In its November 17, 2026 ruling, the Supreme Court rejected that argument.Justice David Wecht, writing for the majority, referred to Section 1127 of the Pennsylvania Public School Code. The provision says that a school board must conduct a hearing before dismissing a tenured professional employee and give that employee an opportunity to be heard “before the board of school directors”.The court interpreted this to mean that at least some elected board members must be present. It held that a hearing conducted with no elected directors in attendance could not be considered a hearing before the board.The judgment stated: “For present purposes, it suffices to say that a hearing with no school directors in attendance is not a hearing ‘before the board of school directors.'”The court also pointed to Section 1129, which requires the board to consider the charges and testimony before voting on a dismissal. It rejected the district’s argument that members could simply review the hearing officer’s findings and vote afterwards.Importantly, the Supreme Court did not specify exactly how many board members must attend such hearings. It said that deciding whether a quorum or a smaller number is sufficient was outside the scope of this case. The question before it was whether all elected directors could stay away. The court’s answer was no.The ruling affirmed the Commonwealth Court’s decision reinstating Follman with back pay, unless and until the district carries out a lawful termination.

What the ruling does and does not decide

The case was not a judgment that Follman’s refusal to undergo Covid testing was justified. The Supreme Court’s decision focused on whether the school district followed the procedure required by law when it dismissed a tenured teacher.The original termination decision had relied on allegations of persistent negligence and wilful neglect of duties. The Secretary of Education had accepted the district’s grounds for dismissal, but the later court proceedings found that the absence of elected board members at the hearing made the termination process legally defective.The ruling therefore centres on the rights of tenured public-school teachers facing dismissal in Pennsylvania. It makes clear that a school board cannot avoid its statutory responsibility by allowing an appointed hearing officer to conduct the entire hearing while every elected director remains absent.


Source link

Related Articles

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Back to top button
×
newsnation.aanest.com
Logo
Date of Publish : 20 November 2026, 2:00 am Digital Edition : News nation
A Philadelphia teacher was fired after refusing weekly Covid tests, but not one elected school board member attended his termination hearing; five years later, Pennsylvania’s top court upheld a ruling in his favour

AI representation/ChatGPT A Philadelphia teacher who lost his job after refusing to undergo weekly Covid-19 tests has won a legal battle that began during the pandemic. The Pennsylvania Supreme Court has ruled in his favour, finding that the school district violated state law by holding his termination hearing without a single elected school board member present.The ruling, delivered on November 17, concerns Neal Follman, a teacher in the School District of Philadelphia. The court upheld an earlier decision ordering the district to reinstate him with back pay unless it properly terminates his employment in accordance with the law.The case turned on a question of procedure: can a school board delegate a tenured teacher's dismissal hearing entirely to an appointed hearing officer, then decide the teacher's fate by reviewing the record afterwards? The state's highest court said no.Why the teacher refused Covid testingAccording to the Pennsylvania Department of Education's official record, Follman was employed by the Philadelphia School District from January 2010 and worked at Constitution High School during the 2020-21 school year.On February 22, 2021, the district's then superintendent, William Hite, informed staff that employees returning to schools for in-person learning would have to undergo weekly Covid-19 testing. The testing was to be carried out by medical providers at school premises during working hours. Employees could seek an exemption on medical grounds.Follman submitted a refusal and exemption request on May 7, 2021. He listed concerns including the test's emergency-use authorisation, its accuracy, the handling of testing materials and the company administering the tests. However, he did not complete the section of the form asking him to provide a justification for a medical exemption.The district told him that his reasons were insufficient and warned that disciplinary action would follow if he continued to refuse testing. Follman maintained his refusal. His school principal, Brianna Dunn-Robb, recommended his termination. A district hearing officer also recommended that he be dismissed and suspended without pay while the decision was pending.The school board initially adopted a resolution supporting the termination recommendation in August 2021. Follman was then issued a statement of charges and given the opportunity to challenge the proposed dismissal.The termination hearing that no elected board member attendedPhoto: CanvaFollman chose to contest the proposed termination through a hearing under Pennsylvania's Local Agency Law. The hearing was initially scheduled for September 13, 2021, but was postponed. The district later decided to hold it virtually, despite objections from Follman and his lawyer, who had sought an in-person hearing.The hearing eventually took place by videoconference in February 2022. No elected member of the Philadelphia Board of Education attended. Instead, the board appointed a hearing officer, Rudolph Garcia, to preside over the proceedings. Follman challenged the arrangement, arguing that Pennsylvania's Public School Code required him to be heard before the elected school board directors themselves.On August 18, 2022, the board voted 9-0 to dismiss him. It adopted the hearing officer's findings and conclusions. The Pennsylvania Department of Education's Secretary of Education initially upheld the dismissal. The secretary reasoned that the board could appoint a hearing officer as long as its members reviewed the findings and made an independent decision based on the record. Follman appealed.What the courts saidIn July 2024, the Commonwealth Court of Pennsylvania reversed the secretary's decision. It held that the school board had not complied with the statutory procedure for dismissing a tenured teacher. The court ordered Follman's reinstatement with back pay unless the district properly terminated his employment.The Philadelphia School District challenged that decision before the Pennsylvania Supreme Court. It argued that the Public School Code allowed school boards to delegate the task of conducting termination hearings to appointed hearing officers. In its November 17, 2026 ruling, the Supreme Court rejected that argument.Justice David Wecht, writing for the majority, referred to Section 1127 of the Pennsylvania Public School Code. The provision says that a school board must conduct a hearing before dismissing a tenured professional employee and give that employee an opportunity to be heard "before the board of school directors".The court interpreted this to mean that at least some elected board members must be present. It held that a hearing conducted with no elected directors in attendance could not be considered a hearing before the board.The judgment stated: "For present purposes, it suffices to say that a hearing with no school directors in attendance is not a hearing 'before the board of school directors.'"The court also pointed to Section 1129, which requires the board to consider the charges and testimony before voting on a dismissal. It rejected the district's argument that members could simply review the hearing officer's findings and vote afterwards.Importantly, the Supreme Court did not specify exactly how many board members must attend such hearings. It said that deciding whether a quorum or a smaller number is sufficient was outside the scope of this case. The question before it was whether all elected directors could stay away. The court's answer was no.The ruling affirmed the Commonwealth Court's decision reinstating Follman with back pay, unless and until the district carries out a lawful termination.What the ruling does and does not decideThe case was not a judgment that Follman's refusal to undergo Covid testing was justified. The Supreme Court's decision focused on whether the school district followed the procedure required by law when it dismissed a tenured teacher.The original termination decision had relied on allegations of persistent negligence and wilful neglect of duties. The Secretary of Education had accepted the district's grounds for dismissal, but the later court proceedings found that the absence of elected board members at the hearing made the termination process legally defective.The ruling therefore centres on the rights of tenured public-school teachers facing dismissal in Pennsylvania. It makes clear that a school board cannot avoid its statutory responsibility by allowing an appointed hearing officer to conduct the entire hearing while every elected director remains absent.

Source link