COP31 ends without climate pact as countries fail to reach consensus over fossil fuel omission and empty finance promises | India News

NEW DELHI: Countries on Sunday failed to reach an agreement at the 31st session of the UN climate conference (COP31) in Antalya, Turkey as there was no consensus over the cover decision (overarching political and binding outcome) — a first such instance since 2009 despite stretching into overtime longer than ever before beyond its schedule time to conclude on Friday — with some countries and groups including EU, Norway and Panama out-rightly objecting to the final deal for not even mentioning a call to transition away from fossil fuels in the text whereas others criticising it for empty climate finance promise.Incidentally, both Turkey and Australia – twin presidencies of this round of climate conference – are fossil fuel producing nations.India while intervening on behalf of the Like-Minded Developing Countries (LMDC) expressed the group’s concerns flagging the “dilution of the historical responsibility and obligations of developed countries” in the text but stopped short of its outright rejection noting that they are “willing to move forward, and continue to engage” for the sake of multilateralism.“Everyone has worked tirelessly, and despite our discomfort with some elements of the text, are willing to move forward, and continue to engage. A constructive approach going forward would be to respect the work we have done and move forward. We are committed to multilateralism and the principles of consensus and we invite our partners to join us as well,” said India’s key negotiator, Amandeep Garg, additional secretary in the environment ministry, in his intervention.China during the final plenary agreed to what India maintained and even said this in as many words but chose to accept the version of the final text to keep things moving forward.“I am deeply disappointed that COP31 has ended without consensus on an overarching outcome. I share the very profound frustration of all those who expected governments to rise to the moment the climate crisis demands,” said the UN secretary-general, Antonio Guterres.The only other time a COP collapsed before 2009 (COP15 in Copenhagen) was COP6 in the Hague in 2000. The COP15 is, however, considered the biggest disappointment in the history of climate negotiations due to its much wider goal where a legally binding climate agreement could not be reached despite much political hype and preparations ahead of it.Though the COP31 accepted a few decisions and even retained an ambitious ’35 by 35′ electrification goal as a key takeaway, most of the developing countries expressed strong dissatisfaction over the unresolved amount for the adaptation finance and a move of deploying carbon capture, utilization and storage (CCUS) by 2035 that called for wider deployment of CO2 removal technologies. Many countries argued that the CCUS move raises serious questions about the direction of global mitigation efforts.Under the ’35 by 35′ target, electricity would supply 35% of global final energy consumption by 2035. At present, the share of electricity in global energy consumption is 23%. The move recognizes the need for stronger grids, storage, system flexibility and better energy access, but the text mentions no specific financial commitments for this aspiration. It also ignored the firm commitment of renewable-powered electrification.In India, electricity currently makes up roughly 22% of the country’s total final energy consumption, with the remainder dominated by oil, coal and natural gas. The country has voluntarily moved quite fast on increasing its renewable footprints, way above many developing countries.COP31 even failed to bridge the overall adaptation finance gap, leaving many developing countries extremely disappointed. India, on behalf of the LMDC, too flagged it in the plenary.“… our partners have refused to engage on the issue of climate finance across different negotiating rooms. In fact, we were told that despite the increasing needs of developing countries due to a problem that we have not caused, we should not expect our developed country partners to even engage on the issue of climate finance, since it was ‘dead in the water’,” Garg told the plenary.Many experts consider COP31 a big political failure as it happened amid wars, geopolitical tensions, economic uncertainty and mounting climate risks. Countries across the globe are facing growing pressures over energy security, industrial competitiveness and public finances, while developing nations struggle with rising adaptation costs and increasingly severe climate impacts. They also flagged that the EU failed miserably to take climate leadership in the absence of the USA which under President Donald Trump stepped out from the Paris Agreement.Developed countries, mainly the EU nations, the UK and Japan resisted measurable commitments to fund climate action while the major fossil fuel producing nations including Saudi Arabia and Russia opposed stronger language on transitioning away from oil, gas and coal. The result was a text that found space for an electrification goal and CCUS but not for strong anti-fossil fuel commitments or public finance needed by developing nations.“The COP 31 outcome reflects an abject lack of political ambition and accountability. Despite negotiations extending till Sunday, countries failed to agree on a meaningful commitment to transition away from fossil fuels or to talk about climate security.
Share your thoughts in the comments
Be respectful · TOI community guidelines
There is over emphasis on the unknown devil of CCUS which presents a grave concern of untested technology, and serious implications to forest and food security in many parts of the world,” said Aarti Khosla, director, Climate Trends.Harjeet Singh, founding director of the Satat Sampada Climate Foundation, said the COP31 failed the people it was meant to protect. “Rich countries refused to put money on the table to help communities prepare for and recover from climate disasters, and handed polluters a free pass instead. No deal is better than a deal that locks in failure. But this cannot become an excuse for more delay: the money and the plan must now come,” he said.
Source link



