A London neighbour withdrew permission to use a passageway leading to a shared garden; a dispute involving a forced gate, changed locks and washing on her patio ended with a £20,000 legal-cost order | World News

A disagreement over who could walk through a narrow passageway at a London property developed into a legal dispute involving damaged locks, a forced gate and privacy complaints. At the centre of the case was Jodie Schloss, a resident who had allowed other occupants of her building to reach a shared garden through a passage beside her flat for years. She eventually withdrew that permission, saying she no longer wanted people passing so close to her home. But Robin Larkins and his elderly father, Derek, challenged the decision, arguing that other residents should not lose access to the garden. As reported by The Independent, the dispute reached court, where the pair were ordered to pay £20,000 towards their neighbour’s legal costs.
London neighbour dispute begins after shared garden access is withdrawn
The dispute concerned a Victorian villa in Strathray Gardens, Swiss Cottage, north London, where Schloss and Robin Larkins both occupy garden flats. The property also contains several other flats, with some reportedly selling for more than £2 million.For approximately three decades, residents living elsewhere in the building had been able to reach the rear garden through a passage running alongside Schloss’s home. She had previously provided keys allowing them to use the route.That arrangement changed in August 2025. Schloss decided she no longer wanted people walking past her front door and withdrew the permission she had previously given. Her legal representative later told the court that the decision was motivated by concerns about privacy, particularly because the passage runs immediately beside her entrance.The change created a disagreement over the practical use of the garden. Although Robin Larkins could reach it directly from his own flat through a back door, the other occupants did not have an equivalent route, according to the evidence presented at the hearing.
CCTV footage features in row over damaged passageway gate
The situation became more contentious in September 2025, when the arguments over access developed into allegations of trespass and interference with the gate. Schloss’s barrister, John Clargo, told the court that Derek Larkins had insisted he was entitled to continue using the passage on 1 September. His son allegedly threatened to remove the gate. Schloss later heard two men discussing whether she was away from the property, and the following morning she discovered damage to the lock.She subsequently found further damage when she returned to collect belongings on 6 September. CCTV footage also became part of the dispute, with Schloss alleging that it showed Robin Larkins had been involved in damaging the lock. The police were contacted after she was informed that Robin, Derek and another person were in the passageway. According to the account given in court, she initially agreed to provide Robin with a key but reconsidered after viewing footage that appeared to show his father using a crowbar.The disagreement did not end there. On 2 October, Robin Larkins changed the gate’s lock without providing Schloss with a key, despite a request from her solicitor. She subsequently changed the locks again.
Family laundry found on neighbour’s private patio amid garden access row
The passageway remained a point of contention into the following year. Schloss’s legal team told the court that Derek Larkins forced the lock on 22 March 2026, allowing the pair to use the route on that date and again on 24 March. A separate incident on 9 April brought another complaint. Washing belonging to the Larkins family was found hanging out to dry on Schloss’s private patio.Robin Larkins addressed the matter during the hearing, saying his cleaner had put the laundry there without realising that the space was private. He added that the cleaner had been instructed not to repeat the mistake. For Schloss, the incidents formed part of a wider pattern of unwanted access to areas she considered her own. She approached the court seeking an injunction to prevent further entry onto the passageway and patio.Her barrister argued that the other occupants had no legal entitlement to use the route simply because they had done so for many years. He also maintained that Robin’s right to use the garden did not give him permission to cross his neighbour’s passageway.
Robin Larkins said he wanted to protect other residents’ access
Representing himself, Robin Larkins disputed the suggestion that his actions were malicious. He told the court that his concern was primarily about the other leaseholders in the building, who had relied on the side passage to reach the garden for around 30 years.He argued that residents had contributed towards garden maintenance through their service charges and should not suddenly be prevented from using the communal space. Larkins said the dispute did not directly affect his own access because he could enter the garden from his flat. His objection, he explained, was about the position of the other occupants, who had no alternative route.Derek Larkins also had a long-standing connection with the property. He had worked as its gardener and general maintenance man for years, a role that involved accessing manholes in the passageway and moving between the garden and other parts of the building.Judge Stephen Hellman, sitting at Mayor’s and City County Court, acknowledged that the withdrawal of access would have come as a surprise to the other residents. He also recognised that the passage was the only way most of them could reach the garden.However, the judge considered the circumstances surrounding the damaged gate and the repeated use of the passage when assessing the conduct of the defendants.
Judge orders father and son to pay £20,000 in legal costs
After a hearing lasting around three hours, Judge Hellman accepted legally binding undertakings from Robin and Derek Larkins. Both agreed not to enter Schloss’s passageway or private patio without her permission while the wider dispute remained unresolved.The judge also ordered the father and son to pay £20,000 towards Schloss’s legal costs. A significant factor in that decision was the conduct surrounding the gate, which the judge heard had been forced open twice by Derek, with his son present on one occasion.The order followed an interim hearing rather than a final determination of every issue between the neighbours. The court is expected to consider the wider dispute at a full trial at a later date, unless the parties reach an agreement beforehand. Judge Hellman indicated that Schloss had a strong case concerning the passageway and warned the defendants that continuing the proceedings unsuccessfully could leave them facing considerably higher legal expenses.Disclaimer: This article is based on publicly available online reports. The Times of India has not independently verified the details of the neighbour dispute or the court proceedings. The £20,000 order relates to legal costs, and the wider dispute remains subject to further court proceedings.
Source link



