World

A BC condo owner who said her neighbours’ scented laundry kept her off her balcony since 2018 has lost her case, after a tribunal ruled laundry smells come from a reasonable, lawful everyday activity | World News

A BC condo owner who said her neighbours’ scented laundry kept her off her balcony since 2018 has lost her case, after a tribunal ruled laundry smells come from a reasonable, lawful everyday activity
A BC condo owner who said her neighbours’ scented laundry kept her off her balcony since 2018 has lost her case, after a tribunal ruled laundry smells come from a reasonable, lawful everyday activity/Image: Getty Images

A condominium owner in British Columbia, Canada, has lost a legal complaint against her neighbours over scented laundry products after a tribunal ruled that the smell from washing and drying clothes was part of an ordinary household activity that residents must tolerate.The woman had argued that fragrances from neighbouring apartments created an “overwhelming stench”, preventing her from opening her windows or spending time on her balcony. She wanted the strata council to enforce its nuisance bylaw and require residents to stop using scented laundry products.However, the province’s Civil Resolution Tribunal dismissed her claim, finding that the source of the odours could not be established and that the use of laundry fragrances did not amount to an unreasonable interference with other residents, according to CTV News.In a decision, tribunal member Alissa Reynolds noted that although the woman said the problem had affected her since 2018, the first formal complaint was recorded in 2023.

Strata council investigated complaints over laundry smells

The strata council, which oversees the condominium’s common property and shared facilities, formed a committee to investigate the woman’s concerns.According to the tribunal decision, the investigation involved identifying dryer vents close to her apartment, visiting neighbouring units and asking residents to stop using and dispose of scented products. The council also circulated a notice to the entire complex requesting that occupants avoid such products.Despite these measures, the woman continued to report the smell.Reynolds said the council could not establish where the odour was coming from after eliminating the nearest dryer vents as possible sources.“I find it is not possible for the (strata council) to identify the ongoing source of (the woman’s) complaints, given it has now eliminated the closest dryer vents,” she wrote.The tribunal also considered the possibility that the smell originated beyond the condominium complex. Reynolds pointed out that the property was situated in a densely populated neighbourhood surrounded by other apartment buildings and businesses.“The (complex) is located in a densely populated community with several neighbouring apartment buildings and businesses, and the scent could be coming from outside the (complex),” the decision stated.

Tribunal says laundry fragrances do not amount to a nuisance

The woman also submitted a physician’s letter confirming that she had multiple chemical sensitivities. She described the laundry odours as “terrible fumes” and argued that they affected her ability to use her home comfortably.However, Reynolds found that the evidence did not establish that fragrances coming specifically from neighbouring dryer vents posed a health risk to the complainant.The tribunal also examined whether the alleged interference met the legal threshold for a nuisance under the strata’s rules. According to the decision, the test requires an activity to cause an unreasonable, continuing or repeated disruption to another resident’s use and enjoyment of their property. The impact must also be substantial rather than minor.Even if the source of the smell had been identified, Reynolds concluded that the use of scented laundry products would not breach the nuisance bylaw.“I find laundry scents are the result of a reasonable and lawful activity and ordinary citizens must tolerate a minor degree of neighbourhood loss of amenity or slight annoyance,” she wrote.The tribunal member added that a reasonable person would not consider the reported interference substantial or non-trivial.


Source link

Related Articles

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Back to top button
×
newsnation.aanest.com
Logo
Date of Publish : 19 November 2026, 6:45 pm Digital Edition : News nation
A BC condo owner who said her neighbours’ scented laundry kept her off her balcony since 2018 has lost her case, after a tribunal ruled laundry smells come from a reasonable, lawful everyday activity | World News

A BC condo owner who said her neighbours’ scented laundry kept her off her balcony since 2018 has lost her case, after a tribunal ruled laundry smells come from a reasonable, lawful everyday activity/Image: Getty Images A condominium owner in British Columbia, Canada, has lost a legal complaint against her neighbours over scented laundry products after a tribunal ruled that the smell from washing and drying clothes was part of an ordinary household activity that residents must tolerate.The woman had argued that fragrances from neighbouring apartments created an “overwhelming stench”, preventing her from opening her windows or spending time on her balcony. She wanted the strata council to enforce its nuisance bylaw and require residents to stop using scented laundry products.However, the province's Civil Resolution Tribunal dismissed her claim, finding that the source of the odours could not be established and that the use of laundry fragrances did not amount to an unreasonable interference with other residents, according to CTV News.In a decision, tribunal member Alissa Reynolds noted that although the woman said the problem had affected her since 2018, the first formal complaint was recorded in 2023.Strata council investigated complaints over laundry smellsThe strata council, which oversees the condominium's common property and shared facilities, formed a committee to investigate the woman's concerns.According to the tribunal decision, the investigation involved identifying dryer vents close to her apartment, visiting neighbouring units and asking residents to stop using and dispose of scented products. The council also circulated a notice to the entire complex requesting that occupants avoid such products.Despite these measures, the woman continued to report the smell.Reynolds said the council could not establish where the odour was coming from after eliminating the nearest dryer vents as possible sources.“I find it is not possible for the (strata council) to identify the ongoing source of (the woman’s) complaints, given it has now eliminated the closest dryer vents,” she wrote.The tribunal also considered the possibility that the smell originated beyond the condominium complex. Reynolds pointed out that the property was situated in a densely populated neighbourhood surrounded by other apartment buildings and businesses.“The (complex) is located in a densely populated community with several neighbouring apartment buildings and businesses, and the scent could be coming from outside the (complex),” the decision stated.Tribunal says laundry fragrances do not amount to a nuisanceThe woman also submitted a physician's letter confirming that she had multiple chemical sensitivities. She described the laundry odours as “terrible fumes” and argued that they affected her ability to use her home comfortably.However, Reynolds found that the evidence did not establish that fragrances coming specifically from neighbouring dryer vents posed a health risk to the complainant.The tribunal also examined whether the alleged interference met the legal threshold for a nuisance under the strata's rules. According to the decision, the test requires an activity to cause an unreasonable, continuing or repeated disruption to another resident's use and enjoyment of their property. The impact must also be substantial rather than minor.Even if the source of the smell had been identified, Reynolds concluded that the use of scented laundry products would not breach the nuisance bylaw.“I find laundry scents are the result of a reasonable and lawful activity and ordinary citizens must tolerate a minor degree of neighbourhood loss of amenity or slight annoyance,” she wrote.The tribunal member added that a reasonable person would not consider the reported interference substantial or non-trivial.

Source link