An Indiana woman who has owned her home since 1989 sued neighbours after they shifted a fence by about a foot in 2022, claiming the grassy strip between their properties; an appeals court ruled the land was not hers

A fence moved by about a foot became the centre of a property dispute between neighbours in Indiana, where a homeowner claimed ownership of a grassy strip separating their properties. The woman, who had owned her house since 1989, argued that the land belonged to her despite the neighbouring owners’ decision to install a replacement fence in 2022. However, the Indiana Court of Appeals ruled against her, finding that she had not established the legal requirements to claim the disputed property.In its November 13, 2026, memorandum decision in Deanne Ellen Gloppen v. Daniel Goldfarb, available on Justia, the appeals court affirmed a lower court ruling in favour of the neighbouring property owners. The judges examined whether Gloppen could establish ownership through adverse possession, a legal principle that can allow someone to acquire another person’s land after meeting specific conditions over a required period. The court concluded that her evidence did not satisfy those conditions, particularly the requirement concerning property taxes.
Dispute began after neighbours moved the fence
Gloppen has owned and lived at her home at 304 Elmhurst Street in Valparaiso, Indiana, since 1989. The neighbouring property at 306 Elmhurst Street has belonged to Daniel and Julia Goldfarb since 2007. The disagreement concerned a grassy strip along the boundary between the two properties. In 2022, the Goldfarbs removed an existing fence and installed a replacement. The new fence stood approximately six to eight inches north of the deeded property boundary and about one foot south of the previous fence.According to the court record, at least three fences had been erected along that side of the Goldfarbs’ property over time, and they had not all occupied the same position. In October 2022, Gloppen filed a lawsuit seeking ownership of the disputed strip through adverse possession. The Goldfarfs opposed her claim and asked the court to recognise their ownership under their property deeds. In June 2025, Gloppen filed a motion for summary judgment, asking the court to establish the boundary between the two properties. After a hearing, the trial court denied her motion and granted the Goldfarfs’ cross-motion. She subsequently appealed the decision.
Court examined adverse possession requirements
The Indiana Court of Appeals considered whether Gloppen had demonstrated the legal elements necessary to establish adverse possession. Under Indiana law, a person claiming land through adverse possession must establish four elements by clear and convincing evidence: control, intent, notice and duration. The claimant must exercise control over the property, demonstrate an intention to claim it as their own, make that claim sufficiently visible to notify the legal owner and maintain the possession continuously for at least 10 years.There is also a separate tax requirement. A claimant must pay the property taxes and special assessments attributable to the disputed land that they reasonably and honestly believe are due. The court found that Gloppen had not established this requirement. She had not provided sufficient evidence that she reasonably believed her property tax payments covered the grassy strip.During the summary judgment proceedings, her lawyer acknowledged that Gloppen paid taxes on the property described in her deed, while the Goldfarfs paid taxes on the property covered by theirs. The judges clarified that adverse possession does not necessarily require a separate tax assessment for the disputed land. However, the claimant must demonstrate a reasonable, good-faith belief that their tax payments cover the property they are attempting to acquire.The court also considered the evidence concerning the fences and the use of the disputed area. Gloppen had not claimed that she maintained or replaced the fences, nor had she demonstrated improvements to the strip that would have alerted the neighbours to an ownership claim.
Appeals court upheld the lower court ruling
Gloppen also relied on an earlier Indiana decision involving a fence that had been mistakenly treated as a property boundary. However, the appeals court explained that the Indiana Supreme Court had subsequently disapproved of that decision’s interpretation of the tax requirement.She additionally appeared to raise an argument based on boundary acquiescence, a legal principle that can apply when neighbouring owners recognise and follow an incorrect boundary for at least 20 years. However, she had not included this claim in her amended complaint and could not introduce it for the first time during the summary judgment proceedings.On November 13, 2026, the Indiana Court of Appeals affirmed the trial court’s decision, leaving ownership of the disputed grassy strip with the Goldfarfs. The ruling was issued as a memorandum decision under Indiana Appellate Rule 65(D). It is not binding precedent for other courts and may generally be cited only for persuasive purposes or in limited circumstances.
Source link



